Will new regulations send the Chinese vid sharing sites down the tubes?
I’m back in action folks, and fortunately not too much China tech/marketing news has slipped by in my absence–or so I’d like to believe.
But this could be big news, and definitely something to watch in the coming months. The Marbridge newsletter today has an intriguing little piece citing Xinhuanet–still looking for the original story–saying that the Ministry of Information Industries (MII) minister Wang Xudong has said that the MII and the State Administration of Radio, Film and Television (SARFT), with the approval of the State Council, will co-issue new rules governing the online audio and video industry in early 2008.
The new rules will limit provision of online audio and video programming to majority state-owned firms. Companies meeting this and other pre-conditions, must then obtain a license from SARFT for the provision of audio and video content, followed by an Internet access permit from the MII.
I rang my friend Victor Koo, former president of Sohu.com and founder and CEO of one of the leading Chinese video sharing sites Youku.com, who told me that this doesn’t actually represent a change in policy: “It’s really just a formalization of the implementation and application process,” he says. “We’ve already been submitting various information they’ve asked us for about our legal structure, and about how we operate. From an operational standpoint it doesn’t make a difference, but from a regulatory perspective it’s going to be similar to when the portals listed.”
There’s definitely precedent for operating in a regulatory gray area until things sort themselves out, and as long as no one crosses major lines–pornography, politically sensitive content–my instincts tell me that none of these regulatory bodies are going to sink a major video sharing or P2P player, as ominous as this bit about limiting online video to majority state-owned firms sounds.
Mark Natkin, who runs Marbridge, agrees. Here’s what he had to say when I spoke to him just now:
Technically most all of the private online video providers are working without the necessary licenses. And that comes in part due to a complication in terms of policy: SARFT is responsible for issuing those licenses, but then the State Council came out with regulations of its own–a moratorium on further issuance of licenses for private Internet video providers. And obviously the State Council [equivalent to the Cabinet] trumps SARFT. There were a couple of companies who received licenses before that [moratorium], like Sina and Tencent. So it’s not the case that every company is operating without a license. But many are–not naming names.
This puts SARFT in a difficult situation in which it would like to issue more licenses but its hands are tied. It’s a gray area. For SARFT, the resources it can devote to monitoring and policing are not infinite. So far the outlook has been that if you give these things enough time, like with many new businesses and industries, they’ll sort themselves out–especially in a business like this where bandwidth costs are so high. China Telecom [China's leading fixed-line carrier and ISP] has been talking in recent weeks about increasing bandwith charges dramatically, even doubling them, and Netcom will likely follow suit. They figure that a lot of these companies will just fall by the wayside by themselves. Already there are rumors that [video sharing company] Ouou.com might be headed that direction.
But I think there’s some real concern about adult video content on certain sites, and also certain political content.
It may be worth adding that, between tighter regulation and higher bandwidth costs, we expect to see significant consolidation in China’s online video industry in 2008. Kicking off the New Year, there have already been insider reports that PPStream and 6.cn are in discussion on a possible merger.
Mark wouldn’t comment on the record about which video sites have been singled out by SARFT for having crossed the line into the realm of the unacceptably naughty, but he intimated that major vid sharing sites have been named.
With literally tens of thousands of new videos uploaded to these vid sharing sites daily, it’s hard to imagine how any of them can keep taboo content from slipping by in-house censors. I don’t envy these guys that task.
Meanwhile, government regulators are only one major concern. As well-funded as the majors (Tudou, Youku, and 56.com) might be, they still face huge server and bandwidth costs that account for upwards of half their monthly burn, and the content delivery networks (CDNs) like ChinaCache CDN–services needed to keep the streaming as fast as Chinese users have come to expect–are relatively expensive, too. And where’s the revenue coming from? One friend of mine tells me that in 2007 to date, one major video site the three leading video sharing sites had combined advertising revenues of only about $6 million.
16 comments thus far
[...] New regulations to send Chinese vid sharing down the tubes?: At Ogilvy’s Digital Watch blog, Kaiser Kuo comments on what MII has in store for 2008, specifically, new regulations that may keep online video in the hands of state-owned or state-controlled companies:I rang my friend Victor Koo, former president of Sohu.com and founder and CEO of one of the leading Chinese video sharing sites Youku.com, who told me that this doesn’t actually represent a change in policy: "It’s really just a formalization of the implementation and application process," he says. "We’ve already been submitting various information they’ve asked us for about our legal structure, and about how we operate. From an operational standpoint it doesn’t make a difference, but from a regulatory perspective it’s going to be similar to when the portals listed." [...]
Posted by Danwei : Danwei Picks: 2007-12-28 on December 28, 2007 at 6:57 pm
[...] students regard it as an “effective way to satisfy their emotional needs”.Kaiser Kuo of the Ogilvy Digital China Watch asks if new regulations will send Chinese vid-sharing websites down the [...]
Posted by Shanghaiist : China Tech Talk: Scientist wages, "internet love" and 47 million bloggers! on December 29, 2007 at 4:18 pm
[...] Will new regulations send the Chinese vid sharing sites down the tubes? (tags: 在线视频 cmd) [...]
Posted by links for 2007-12-29 at Oh My Media on December 30, 2007 at 7:14 am
[...] 国家广播电影电视总局、中华人民共和国信息产业部12月29日公布了将于2008年1月31日施行的《互联网视听节目服务管理规定》。各大网站均有转载,例如中国新闻网。一些英文blog似乎曾对此规定还有乐观态度,认为“从操作层面上看跟过去没什么不同”。但真正看到后,估计他们多少会有点吃惊。 [...]
Posted by 《互联网视听节目服务管理规定》之个人解读 at Oh My Media on December 30, 2007 at 8:39 am
[...] 国家广播电影电视总局、中华人民共和国信息产业部12月29日公布了将于2008年1月31日施行的《互联网视听节目服务管理规定》。各大网站均有转载,例如中国新闻网。一些英文blog似乎曾对此规定还有乐观态度,认为“从操作层面上看跟过去没什么不同”。但真正看到后,估计他们多少会有点吃惊。 [...]
Posted by Hans Virus » Blog Archive » 《互联网视听节目服务管理规定》之个人解读 on December 30, 2007 at 1:09 pm
[...] 国家广播电影电视总局、中华人民共和国信息产业部12月29日公布了将于2008年1月31日施行的《互联网视听节目服务管理规定》。各大网站均有转载,例如中国新闻网。一些英文blog似乎曾对此规定还有乐观态度,认为“从操作层面上看跟过去没什么不同”。但真正看到后,估计他们多少会有点吃惊。 [...]
Posted by 《互联网视听节目服务管理规定》之个人解读 | Sail's Sphere on December 30, 2007 at 5:43 pm
Interesting, I wonder how it will effect other sites and services such as Blin or PPStream, UUSee etc rather than just the youtube ripoffs.
One CEO of a leading video site told me that well over half the searches on the site are for “adult-related content” so I wonder how much of that actual content is out there and how long it stays up (interesting research project for you kaiser!!!)Same person also told me the government crack down far harder on anti-government content than pornography or violence and they make almost no requests to remove the copyrighted content which makes up around 80% of the submissions!
The simple fact is that many chinese consumers are fed up with the low quality content available to them on TV and are using technology (from Internet to mobile to good old fake DVD’s) to get it. There’s often a lag as the government adapts regulation to fit new technologies and this announcement does seem like a formalisation of that, guess we’ll see how it plays out - wonder if there are a few nervous VC’s out there!
As for your point on revenues its not just the chinese sites, I imagine Google is going to have to wait quite a long time to recoup the $1.5bn they spent on Youtube, but at least they have got deep pockets!
Posted by scott on December 30, 2007 at 6:37 pm
[...] From Oh My Media by maomy Shared by keso 在 线视频作为新兴的互联网服务,在中国日益繁荣兴旺,前有youtube的成功,后有投资人和媒体的呐喊,上百家视频网站(这还不包括市以上各级电信网通的 论坛网站提供的在线看电影听歌或下载)早已厮杀作一团。在线音频尽管“钱景”不如视频可观,但相对较低的门槛使之成为个人发布微内容的常见选择,也催生出 “反波”这样网民喜爱的草根媒体。对这样一块热闹的“阵地”,缺乏管制只是因为管制办法尚在研究中。 国家广播电影电视总局、中华人民共和国信息产业部12月29日公布了将于2008年1月31日施行的《互联网视听节目服务管理规定》。各大网站均有转载,例如中国新闻网。一些英文blog似乎曾对此规定还有乐观态度,认为“从操作层面上看跟过去没什么不同”。但真正看到后,估计他们多少会有点吃惊。 从头至尾读过两遍,初步感受:又一部针对互联网的行政规章,而且又是一项典型的只讲“公权力”,不讲“私权利”,只讲“管理”不讲“服务”的行政立 法。曾看过有法律学者论述道,法治之根本在于对公共权力的限制或控制;但我们似乎只看到管制型的互联网相关行政立法,着眼点一是控制“权利”,二是扩张 “权力”。 这部规章是否合乎法理,立法依据是什么(规章中并没写明),这些留待法学专家们来探讨。在我看来,本规定要点如下: [...]
Posted by 乌龟速度 » Blog Archive » 《互联网视听节目服务管理规定》之个人解读 on December 31, 2007 at 3:01 am
[...] and Television) and MII (Ministry of Information Industries) regulations on online video, which I wrote about briefly after the MII Minister Wang Xudong made an announcement about their implementation the [...]
Posted by SARFT and MII regulations on online video - Marbridge on January 2, 2008 at 10:02 am
This regulation seems to target larger video sharing site(s) such as tudou.com and/or youku.com. As a smaller private content provider (please check out our site at http://www.ivivi.cn) , how does one even go about with compliance? More info would be appreciated.
Posted by Tom Lin on January 7, 2008 at 9:35 pm
@Tom Lin - I wouldn’t be the one to ask. I would suggest that you contact SARFT through the number on their Website and explain your situation to them and that you’re interested in ensuring that you’re in compliance. Best of luck!
Posted by Kaiser Kuo on January 8, 2008 at 6:24 am
[...] tidligere præsident for Sohu.com og direktør for en af videoportalerne, youku.com, mener heller ikke, at loven er nogen betydelig ændring: “It’s really just a formalization of the implementation [...]
Posted by Censur på internettet: Nye regler for videoportaler i Kina | KINABLOG.dk on January 11, 2008 at 4:19 pm
[...] private companies are expected to find a work around. Kaiser Kuo estimates on his DigitalWatch Ogilvy blog a continuation of operations, without having Chinese businesses crossing legal limits. “There’s [...]
Posted by Businesses expected to work around China’s recent online video restrictions : Institute for the Networked Future (INF) on January 31, 2008 at 10:17 pm
[...] Will new regulations send the Chinese vid sharing sites down the tubes? [...]
Posted by Hydwin Blawgs » China Issued ‘Regulations for Online Audio and Video Services’ on February 22, 2008 at 4:09 pm
[...] Will new regulations send the Chinese vid sharing sites down the tubes? [...]
Posted by links for 2008-01-08 | Oh My Media | 媒介与 on February 29, 2008 at 8:37 am
This regulation seems to target larger video sharing site(s) such as tudou.com and/or youku.com.
Sohbet
Posted by sohbet on December 4, 2008 at 7:06 am
Post a new comment